24-bit FLAC is a digital format capable of capturing dynamic range far beyond human hearing and beyond the physical limits of vinyl. A vinyl record’s groove, at its absolute best, can deliver about 65-70 dB of dynamic range. A 24-bit digital file can theoretically handle 144 dB. You’re using a space shuttle computer to measure the height of a garden fence.

And that—that contradiction—is the real story.

James Taylor’s Greatest Hits (1976) is a cultural landmark. It’s the album that defined "singer-songwriter" for the masses. But its original vinyl pressing was famously not an audiophile product. It was a budget-priced, mass-market compilation from Warner Bros. The vinyl was thin, the mastering was compressed for car radios and portable record players, and the pressing plants were churning out millions of copies. A first-pressing Greatest Hits is not rare, and sonically, it’s just "fine."